Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in the August 2026 print edition of Greenhouse Management under the headline “Don’t make pore substrate decisions.”

Soilless substrates in floriculture production today are an entirely different monster than at their dawn in the late 1950s. In the past, we typically had limited and straightforward options; fast forward to 2026, we operate in such a large and diverse market, it can be overwhelming to choose from myriad substrate options now available.
Like going grocery shopping and standing in front of an aisle filled with seemingly hundreds of different brands and options for the same item, where do you even begin? Choosing new soilless substrates, either with a different supplier or a different recipe with the same supplier, is not as simple as changing ice cream flavors.
In this article, we share some considerations you can use as a checklist when selecting your next substrate batch.
Consideration 1: Physical properties
Drink tank
After irrigation, substrates will have a unique ratio of pores filled with either water or air. Companies will express water-filled pores with terms like water retention, container capacity, water storage, etc. It’s incredibly important to remember that this value only represents the maximum amount of water a substrate can hold after an irrigation and that substrate moisture does not remain constant at this value. Depending on the substrate, irrigation, growth stage and climate, this water retention value may quickly decrease or slightly change.
Recommended substrate water retention values range from 45% to 65%. Consider asking your substrate supplier about available versus unavailable water or the amount of water between water retention and when the plant begins to wilt.
Fish grow in water; plants grow in air
Of course, water is vital for plants, though in a general sense, oxygen exchange and air space are much more important for containerized crops. Often called air space, air-filled porosity or drainage, this critical substrate characteristic should be prioritized for a few reasons. Roots can still access moisture when “dry,” yet a few minutes without oxygen can injure roots. Roots need oxygen to grow and to actively absorb water and nutrients. And if the rootzone needs more water, the solution is simple and quick: irrigate. If the rootzone needs more oxygen, the only solution is time.
Air space recommendations range from 10% to 30%. A word of caution: Greater air space values typically translate to lower water retention. Ask your substrate supplier if they have substrates that contain adequate values of both water retention and air space.
If it’s not a pore, it’s a particle
Substrates come in all shapes and sizes, otherwise known as particles. Substrate suppliers can engineer the pore spaces (how much water and air are stored) by changing the particle type, shape and size. A general rule of thumb is that finer particles will increase water retention, while coarser particles will increase air space and drainage. Finer particles can also help increase lateral water movement during irrigation, whereas larger particles can often result in quick channeling. Keep these properties in mind when exploring new substrate formulations. Remember to ask your supplier: What is the particle size distribution?
Walk away from the dry side
Often, substrate manufacturers will add wetting agents as a liquid or granular to their formulations to overcome hydrophobicity, which can be a grower’s worst nightmare, especially when you have wilted plants that need water. Wetting agents help rehydrate the substrate and can promote more lateral infiltration. Substrates like peat moss and pine bark are known to become hydrophobic when dry, while others like coconut coir and wood fiber are well-equipped to rehydrate. When purchasing already-formulated substrates, confirm that wetting agents are pre-applied. Post-transplanting, ensure your substrates are well-hydrated to limit initial hydrophobicity.
Consideration 2: Chemical properties
Put the lime in the peat, bark, wood fiber, etc.
Don’t let this shake you up. Substrate pH is vitally important because it determines the availability of macro- and micronutrients needed by the plant. A pH of 5.5 to 6.2 is generally considered the “sweet spot” for applied mineral nutrients, because essential nutrients are most available in this range. Substrate base materials and amendments can be vastly different in terms of source material, processing and pH levels, for example.
Peat generally has a low pH, sitting anywhere between 3.5 and 4.5. Pine bark can have a wide window, from 3.7 to 6.0. Wood fiber typically is between 4.5 to 6.2, but due to tree species, processing methods and seasonality of harvest, this can be as low as 3.8 or as high as 6.0. Coconut coir is often higher, ranging from 5.5 to 6.8. Perlite is a non-organic, inert additive and is generally neutral in pH. Due to these pH ranges, lime often needs to be added to increase pH to optimum levels.

Consideration 3: Compatibility with production systems
Finding a match
Everyone has their unique variables and operational hurdles to juggle, as no two greenhouse growers have the same system. Choosing a substrate that seamlessly fits in with your specific operation can be challenging.
When choosing a substrate, a “chicken or the egg” type of quandary may arise: “Can this fit with my current production system?” or “Will I need to purchase another machine to better optimize my operation?”
Equipment
Depending on the size and scale of your operation, your site may be fine with smaller 3-square-foot bales, which are almost immediately ready to be installed on the potting line and filled in a container.
However, if you’re a larger operation, you’ll likely be interested in purchasing skyscrapers that hold 110 square feet of substrate. A bale shaver is highly recommended as well. If you use degradable type pots and use automation, what role will your media play when bound in the container material? In terms of the hopper, will changing the particle shape and size result in particles remaining stuck inside?
Irrigation
Irrigation type, delivery and scheduling will change based on different substrates. When managing substrates, do your current substrates (or substrates you’d like to purchase) match your existing irrigation system?
If using boom overhead irrigation, finer materials may be more efficient in capturing water, hydrating post-irrigation and facilitating lateral water movement, while coarser materials require longer irrigation or greater application volumes. If your operation irrigates once per day, will this substrate maintain sufficient moisture for 24 hours or require multiple irrigations throughout the day?
Containers
Some substrates are tailored toward seedlings and trays versus finishing mixes with 6-inch pots or trade #1 pots. Peat-based mixes have been a staple in both, but newer materials like wood fiber mixes can take time to learn how to manage. If used in a plug tray, wood fiber has the potential to bridge cells and make it difficult to fill.
The size of the container also drives drainage. High water-holding materials like coconut coir when placed in a trade #1 may have adequate drainage, but placing that same material in a 144-cell may create a perched water table and low oxygen environments.

Consideration 4: Cost and supply
Nickels and dimes, substrates and money signs
“Come on, come on, listen to the money talk” is the classic AC/DC lyric that accurately describes what, unfortunately, can drive production decisions: costs. Sometimes, what is reflected in the invoice may have the ultimate say.
It’s important to remember that we work in such a diverse market, with several options and the ability to fine-tune substrate formulations with different materials. While materials like peat moss, coconut coir and biochar remain high-quality and expensive materials, ask your substrate supplier about pine bark (screened particles), wood fiber and other materials that can be incorporated to help deflate costs but maintain desired properties.
The ‘ables’: Reliable and available
The cliche “consistency is key” maintains more than enough latitude when dealing with substrates. Batch-to-batch uniformity is critical because we all strive to grow uniform crops. But when batches of similar materials differ in properties like pH or particle size, or contain impurities like weed seeds, growth can go astray.
The old proverb “don’t put all your eggs in one basket” holds true for lessening the reliance on substrate sources. In this industry, we see that annual and global differences in surplus or deficits can create uncertainty in supply chains.
It’s difficult to predict substrate availability; however, the advantage of such diverse markets is we have the tools to create unique formulations and mimic desired properties. Always prepare to have backup materials in case of deficit conditions.
Consideration 5: Consumer perception
The media on media
Peat-based substrates have been somewhat vilified due to their environmental impacts and sustainability. Peat bogs are known as “carbon sinks,” meaning that they capture carbon from the atmosphere and store it in the bogs themselves. Thus, harvesting peat is like a carbon “burp” that releases it back into the atmosphere, along with subsequent habitat loss, etc.
Public perception and foreign government legislation has obscured the utilization of peat moss in horticulture. Since peat moss remains the most optimal substrate to date, it becomes difficult to avoid using. There are ways to communicate to consumers when your substrates come from responsibly managed peatland with conservation and rehabilitation efforts in place.

Spotlight on perlite
Perlite is another substrate that stands out for environmentally conscious users. Shipping costs continue to increase, and the material typically cannot be included within composting piles. Perlite can also be hazardous to inhale in its dry dust form. As a result, many operation managers are looking to shift away from its use, especially when they are mixing their own bulk substrates.
Education to consumers regarding substrate science is imperative for the growth of our industry. Many growers still choose to use perlite because it provides excellent air space and drainage. However, some producers include perlite simply because consumers expect to see it (even if they don’t know what it is).
Consideration 6: Roots
As above, so below
Everything we do in rootzone management is designed to generate healthy root systems. Aeration and gas exchange can have a pivotal role in promoting fibrous and dense root systems.
At the same time, moisture availability and uniformity in the container is critical in stimulating roots to grow uniformly throughout the container and outward, rather than straight down toward the container base.
Generally, fine particles help promote root-substrate contact, which can help stimulate lateral roots to develop and explore the new substrate home.
Explore the August 2026 Issue
Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read.
Latest from Greenhouse Management
- The Growth Industry Episode 17: Investing in IGCs with WorryFree® Plants
- New UF study sheds light on the hidden toll of back pain among horticulture workers
- 2026 Irrigation and Automation Market Report: Tradition rains
- Empowering the Future of Precision Cultivation: Resource Efficiency, Root-Zone Science and Scalable Automation
- Oasis Grower Solutions hires plant scientist Timothy Frey
- New green industry leadership development program for women now available
- Clean production protocol
- Jiffy hosting Microgreens Grower Day