How CEA can push organic fertilizer adoption and market expansion

CEA is a beneficiary of circular fertilizer systems and is one of the most capable environments for proving and scaling them.

Leafy greens growing under sunlight in a commercial glass greenhouse.

Photo © DimaBerlin / Adobestock

When the oil embargo hit in 1973, controlled environment agriculture growers faced an existential threat.

Energy costs — already a significant share of operating budgets — suddenly spiraled beyond what many operations could sustain. The industry's response was not to simply absorb the pain or wait for prices to fall. It innovated.

Double-pane glazing, thermal screens and environmental controls resulted in substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and energy use. Crisis, in that case, became the catalyst for a structural leap forward.

In the decades that followed, that same mindset — a willingness to invest in efficiency and innovation — continued to shape the industry. In the late 2000s, when crude oil prices reached up to $147 per barrel and fuel oil used to heat greenhouses tripled in price, the focus again shifted toward energy-use efficiency and alternative fuel sources such as biofuels and cogeneration technologies.

Over the past 10 years, the adoption of LED lighting has further improved energy efficiency and crop control, driven by declining costs, increased reliability and clear performance advantages. While not a direct outcome of the oil crisis, LEDs reflect the same progressive character that defines CEA’s ability to adapt and lead.

We are now facing an analogous moment, but this time, the input under pressure extends beyond energy. It is fertilizer.

A shortage hidden in plain sight

The warning signs have been building for years, but current geopolitical events have made them more visible.

The Strait of Hormuz — the narrow passage through which a substantial share of the world’s fertilizer trade flows — is under sustained disruption, with no clear sight of resolution. Any obstruction along this route raises the real prospect of supply interruptions to the nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium products on which the global agricultural system depends.

This risk is compounded by the region's concentration of supply: In 2025, the Middle East provided approximately 35% of global urea, over a quarter of ammonia trade, just above 20% of phosphates, and roughly 45% of sulfur exports moved through the Strait.

This is not a hypothetical risk. The fertilizer price spikes of 2021 and 2022, triggered in part by the war in Ukraine and the sudden loss of Russian and Belarusian exports, offered a preview of what sustained disruption can look like, with urea prices tripling.

Fertilizer prices are projected to remain elevated above pre-disruption levels — the renormalization process is expected to extend beyond 2027, as both production capacity and infrastructure have been significantly impaired.

This sustained pressure will serve as an indirect but powerful incentive to develop alternative nutrient sources, as a real market need emerges to supply local growers at affordable prices.

CEA producers are not immune to this vulnerability. Liquid fertilizers, water-soluble compounds and the synthetic nutrients used in hydroponic and aeroponic systems originate largely from the same geographically concentrated supply chains that serve field agriculture. When those chains are disrupted, the efficiency advantages of indoor production offer little protection.

Supply chain risk alone would be significant. But synthetic fertilizer production carries an additional burden that has long been accepted as unavoidable — and increasingly, it is not.

The Haber-Bosch process, developed in the early twentieth century, enabled the industrial fixation of atmospheric nitrogen into ammonia, making it available at scale. It is arguably one of the most consequential technological developments in agricultural history.

It is also highly energy-intensive, operating at temperatures exceeding 400 °C and pressures up to 200 atmospheres, driven primarily by natural gas.

Today, Haber-Bosch production accounts for approximately 1% to 2% of global energy consumption, and the synthetic nitrogen fertilizer supply chain accounts for approximately 2.1% of global greenhouse gas emissions.

For an industry increasingly positioned as the sustainable future of food production, continued dependence on synthetic nitrogen presents a structural contradiction.

On-farm nitrogen sources

The fertilizer shocks triggered by the Russia-Ukraine war did more than disrupt supply chains — they accelerated a shift in the industry's view of nitrogen.

Governments and industry worked to stabilize supply: trade flows were rerouted, production expanded where possible and support mechanisms were deployed to protect agricultural output, particularly in low- and middle-income countries.

While these efforts prevented a collapse in fertilizer use, they also revealed a deeper vulnerability — a system heavily dependent on centralized, energy-intensive production and long-distance trade.

In response, attention has increasingly turned toward “green nitrogen”: low-emission ammonia production, bio-based fertilizers and nutrient recovery systems, which is a shift away from fossil fuel dependence and toward more sustainable and resilient nutrient sources.

Interest in localized fertilizer production has grown in parallel, with investments moving toward regional and distributed systems that produce nutrients closer to where they are used, reducing exposure to disruption and improving supply reliability.

Within this context, one of the most immediate opportunities lies in recovering nitrogen already present within agricultural systems. Poultry and livestock operations generate large volumes of ammonia-rich emissions, typically treated as a waste management challenge.

Yet ammonia is nitrogen — and when captured and converted, it becomes a valuable fertilizer input. Technologies are now being deployed to recover ammonia from dairy, swine and poultry operations and convert it into bio-based ammoniacal fertilizers.

A range of OMRI-approved organic nitrogen fertilizers are available to support this approach in practice. These products have been reviewed and listed by the Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI) as compliant with organic standards, and many are well-suited for integration into CEA fertigation systems.

A full, searchable list of OMRI-listed nitrogen fertilizers can be found at omri.org/omri-search.

The case for circular fertilizers

The case for circular fertilizers is both environmental and operational. Capturing ammonia from livestock waste prevents its release into the atmosphere, where it contributes to particulate matter formation, ecosystem acidification and the generation of nitrous oxide (N₂O) — a greenhouse gas with nearly 270 times the warming potential of CO₂.

Recovering this nitrogen simultaneously reduces reliance on energy-intensive Haber-Bosch production, lowering the carbon footprint of fertilizer use while transforming a waste stream into a productive asset.

Beyond the environmental benefits, circular fertilizers introduce a fundamentally different supply model — more localized, more resilient and less exposed to global market volatility. Producing nutrients closer to where they are used decouples input costs from natural gas price fluctuations and reduces dependence on geopolitically sensitive trade routes. This model also aligns with organic certification pathways and growing market demand for sustainable production.

Controlled environment agriculture is uniquely positioned to support and scale this model. Unlike field systems, CEA operations deliver nutrients directly to the root zone with high precision, operate closed-loop systems that recirculate nutrient solutions and minimize losses to leaching and runoff.

These characteristics allow organic liquid fertilizers — including those derived from ammonia capture systems like EcoPower 2 used at 80 Acres Farms — to be used with a level of consistency and efficiency that is difficult to achieve in open-field agriculture. CEA is not simply a beneficiary of circular fertilizer systems; it is one of the most capable environments for proving and scaling them.

From nutrient dependency to nutrient resilience

The opportunity in front of the industry today is not merely defensive — it is transformational. What is at stake is not just securing fertilizer supply, but fundamentally redesigning how nutrients are produced, distributed and used: shifting from centralized to decentralized systems, from extractive models to circular ones and from volatility to resilience.

The conditions for this transition have never been more favorable. Technologies for ammonia capture and nutrient recovery are proven. Nitrogen-rich waste streams are abundant and underutilized. Regulatory pressures are increasing, and the CEA sector has the technical capability to lead.

The convergence of sustained price pressure, supply chain vulnerability and constrained availability creates both a need and an opportunity for public and private investment in localized, renewable fertilizer systems.

Today’s nutrient challenges present a clear inflection point — with an opportunity not just to respond, but to build a circular, locally anchored fertility system that is both economically and environmentally durable.

The question is not whether this transition is possible, but whether the industry will choose to lead it. If it does, there is a real possibility that we will look back on this period as the moment when fertilizer systems began to evolve — not only because of external pressures, but because the industry chose to act.

Achieving that progress without being forced by crisis would be ideal, but history suggests that transformation often requires urgency.

Author's note: This article was inspired by discussions at the University of Arizona CEAC 25th Annual Short Course in April 2026.

Erico Mattos, Ph.D., is a plant scientist, agricultural technology entrepreneur and research leader with more than 15 years of experience in controlled environment agriculture. He co-founded two AgTech companies, directed the Greenhouse Lighting & Systems Engineering consortium at Cornell University, and led commercial R&D and agronomy programs at Soli Organic and 80 Acres Farms. His work combines crop physiology, environmental controls, technology development and sustainable production practices to improve agricultural systems' productivity, resource efficiency and resilience.

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Produce Grower or GIE Media.

No more results found.
No more results found.
Switch Website: Greenhouse Management